Timothée Chalamet’s Bob Dylan Biopic ‘A Complete Unknown’ Reviewed as ‘Frustratingly Basic’ by The Scotsman

Anticipation has surrounded the upcoming Bob Dylan biopic, “A Complete Unknown,” directed by James Mangold and starring Timothée Chalamet as the iconic musician. However, an early review from The Scotsman suggests the film may fall short of expectations, describing it as a “frustratingly basic” offering.

Early Critical Assessment

The Scotsman’s review, one of the first assessments to emerge for the film, highlights a perceived lack of depth despite the compelling subject matter. The verdict of “frustratingly basic” implies that while the film covers the necessary ground, it may fail to capture the complex nuances and revolutionary spirit of Bob Dylan’s early career and profound influence on music and culture.

Focusing on Musical Evolution

The film, which holds a 15 rating, is centered around Dylan’s pivotal musical evolution. This period, likely encompassing his transition from folk troubadour to electric rock pioneer, is a critical phase in Dylan’s story, marked by creative shifts and reactions from his fanbase. Biopics covering such transformative moments often delve deep into the artistic process, influences, and the external pressures faced by the subject. The Scotsman’s critique raises questions about how effectively “A Complete Unknown” navigates this rich narrative terrain.

Narrative Choices and Characters

While focusing on musical evolution, the film also incorporates fictionalized elements, notably a love triangle. This involves folk singer Joan Baez, portrayed by Monica Barbaro, and an invented character, Sylvie Russo, played by Elle Fanning. The summary explicitly states that Sylvie Russo serves as a proxy for Dylan’s actual girlfriend at the time, Suze Rotolo. The inclusion of a fictionalized love triangle is a common narrative device in biographical dramas, often intended to heighten emotional stakes or streamline complex personal histories. However, in the context of a figure as scrutinized as Bob Dylan, such creative liberties can be points of contention for critics and fans alike, potentially contributing to a perception of the film being less than fully authentic or, as described, “basic.”

Monica Barbaro’s portrayal of Joan Baez adds a layer of historical connection, as Baez was a significant figure in the folk music scene and had a documented relationship with Dylan. The decision to create the Sylvie Russo character instead of directly featuring Suze Rotolo, who was a key figure during Dylan’s Greenwich Village years and appeared on the cover of his album The Freewheelin’ Bob Dylan, is a notable narrative choice that the review’s descriptor might implicitly critique.

Production and Release Context

Directed by James Mangold, known for biographical films like Walk the Line, which explored the life of Johnny Cash, “A Complete Unknown” comes with a pedigree that might have suggested a more robust critical reception. Mangold’s experience with musical biopics set expectations high for his handling of the Dylan story. The film was scheduled to be in cinemas from January 17, alongside other reviewed films, marking its entry into the competitive cinematic landscape. The 15 rating indicates content deemed suitable for audiences aged 15 and over, typically involving moderate language, violence, or themes.

Broader Implications

An early review labeling the film “frustratingly basic” poses a challenge for its initial rollout. For a film about an artist celebrated for his complexity, lyrical depth, and enigmatic persona, a ‘basic’ treatment might be seen as missing the essence of the subject. Audiences and critics often look for biopics to offer new insights or perspectives on well-known figures. If “A Complete Unknown” is perceived as merely chronicling events without exploring the deeper currents of Dylan’s artistry and impact, it could temper enthusiasm.

As more reviews emerge, a clearer picture of the film’s overall critical standing will develop. However, The Scotsman’s initial assessment sets a cautious tone, suggesting that despite the promising cast led by Timothée Chalamet and the rich source material, “A Complete Unknown” may not fully capture the elusive magic of Bob Dylan’s legend.