Broadway Review: Jonathan Groff Shines as Bobby Darin in “Just in Time”

“Just in Time” Premieres on Broadway, Jonathan Groff Takes Center Stage as Bobby Darin

New York, NY – The highly anticipated new Broadway musical, “Just in Time,” chronicling the dynamic life and career of legendary American singer Bobby Darin, officially opened its doors on April 26, 2025. The production, staged at the intimate Circle in the Square Theatre in the heart of New York City, features a star-studded cast led by 2024 Tony Award winner Jonathan Groff, whose performance as Darin has already garnered significant attention for its sheer exuberance and captivating energy.

Directed by acclaimed Tony winner Alex Timbers, known for his visually inventive and genre-bending theatrical work, “Just in Time” aims to transport audiences directly into the vibrant world Darin inhabited. The production boasts an ambitious, immersive nightclub setting, masterfully designed by Tony-winning scenic designer Derek McLane. This unique environment is further enhanced by Justin Townsend’s maximalist lighting design, which plays a crucial role in shaping the mood and atmosphere of the show, drawing audiences into the narrative and the musical performances.

Chronicling a Life Through Song and Story

The musical’s narrative delves into the complex and fascinating life of Bobby Darin, exploring his rise to fame, personal struggles, and enduring musical legacy. The story unfolds through a blend of biographical storytelling and electrifying musical numbers, featuring many of Darin’s most beloved hits. Audiences are treated to performances of iconic songs that defined his career, including the swing classic “Beyond the Sea,” the playful pop hit “Splish Splash,” and his signature, gravelly rendition of Kurt Weill and Bertolt Brecht’s “Mack the Knife.”

The book for “Just in Time” was penned by a formidable writing team: Tony winner Warren Leight and Isaac Oliver. Their work is based on an original concept developed by Ted Chapin, a respected figure in the theatre community. The choreography, essential to bringing the musical numbers to life and capturing the style of the era, was created by Shannon Lewis. Music supervision and arrangements, vital components in translating Darin’s distinctive sound for the stage, were expertly handled by Andrew Resnick.

A Cast Bringing Darin’s World to Life

While Jonathan Groff’s portrayal of Bobby Darin is a central focus, the production features a deep and talented ensemble cast bringing key figures from Darin’s life and career to the stage. Among the notable performers is Erika Henningsen, who takes on the role of actress Sandra Dee, Darin’s wife. Tony winner Michele Pawk is also featured in the cast, bringing her considerable stage presence to a pivotal role. The company includes Joe Barbara, Emily Bergl, and Gracie Lawrence, who portrays singer Connie Francis, a contemporary and friend of Darin’s.

Rounding out the diverse and skilled cast are Lance Roberts, Caesar Samayoa, Christine Cornish, Julia Grondin, Valeria Yamin, John Treacy Egan, Tari Kelly, Matt Magnusson, Khori Michelle Petinaud, and Larkin Reilly. Their collective performances contribute to the rich tapestry of the show, supporting the central narrative and enhancing the immersive atmosphere of the production.

Design and Performance Earn Praise

Initial reviews and audience reactions have particularly highlighted Jonathan Groff’s performance, noting his remarkable ability to capture Darin’s charisma and energy, delivering a truly exuberant portrayal. Critics have also pointed to the production’s ambitious design elements – the immersive nightclub setting by Derek McLane and the dramatic lighting by Justin Townsend – as key strengths that elevate the theatrical experience.

“Just in Time” arrives on Broadway as a ambitious exploration of a legendary performer’s life, anchored by a compelling central performance and surrounded by innovative design and a talented ensemble. It promises to be a significant addition to the New York theatre season, inviting audiences to step back in time and experience the world of Bobby Darin anew.