Stranger Things: The First Shadow Broadway Prequel Announces Complete Cast for 2025 Premiere

New York, NY – The eagerly anticipated theatrical production, “Stranger Things: The First Shadow,” has officially unveiled its complete principal cast, setting the stage for its debut on Broadway in 2025. This prequel to the globally successful Netflix science fiction-horror series is poised to delve into the origins of the “Stranger Things” universe through a live stage adaptation.

The production is scheduled to commence preview performances at the Marquis Theatre on Broadway starting March 28, 2025. The official opening night is slated for April 22, 2025, marking a significant expansion of the “Stranger Things” narrative into the live theatrical realm.

Leading the Ensemble

The casting announcement confirms a lineup featuring established and emerging talent, bringing key characters from the prequel narrative to life. Louis McCartney, who originated the role of Henry Creel in the play’s initial West End run, will reprise his performance for the Broadway production. Creel’s character is central to the lore of the “Stranger Things” series, and McCartney’s return provides continuity for those who may have followed the show’s development across the Atlantic.

The cast will also feature Rosie Benton in the role of Virginia Creel. The Creel family name is synonymous with some of the most mysterious and dark elements of the series’ mythology, and Virginia’s portrayal is expected to shed further light on this lineage.

Joining them is Alex Breaux as Dr. Brenner. Dr. Brenner, often referred to as “Papa,” is a pivotal and morally complex figure within the “Stranger Things” narrative, known for his connections to the Upside Down and his relationship with Eleven. Breaux’s casting suggests a deep exploration of Brenner’s past.

Iconic Figures in Earlier Incarnations

The production will also introduce audiences to earlier versions of beloved characters from the television series. Nicky Eldridge has been cast as Bob Newby. Bob Newby, fondly remembered by fans, played a vital role in later seasons of the show, and seeing his character in a prequel context offers a fresh perspective on his history.

Andrew Hovelson will portray Principal Newby. The inclusion of Principal Newby suggests the story will touch upon the educational and community aspects of Hawkins, Indiana, even in earlier years, providing context for the setting familiar to viewers.

Alison Jaye will step into the role of Joyce Maldonado. Before she was Joyce Byers, the fiercely protective mother played by Winona Ryder in the series, she was Joyce Maldonado. Jaye’s performance is anticipated to explore the character’s formative years, revealing aspects of her personality and background that shaped the woman fans know.

The cast announcement also includes the acclaimed actor T.R. Knight. While his specific role in the production was not detailed in the initial announcement, Knight’s participation adds another layer of significant talent to the ensemble, promising compelling performances.

A New Chapter for Hawkins

“Stranger Things: The First Shadow” is set to transport audiences back in time, exploring events that predate the first season of the Netflix phenomenon. By focusing on characters like Henry Creel, Dr. Brenner, and younger iterations of figures like Joyce and Bob, the play aims to uncover foundational elements of the story world.

The decision to launch this theatrical prequel on Broadway underscores the cultural impact and widespread appeal of the “Stranger Things” franchise. Broadway’s Marquis Theatre, a renowned venue in the heart of New York City’s theater district, provides a prestigious platform for this ambitious production.

Anticipation Builds

The complete casting reveal marks a crucial step toward the production’s premiere. With previews beginning in late March 2025 and the official opening in April, theatergoers and “Stranger Things” fans alike are anticipating the opportunity to witness the unfolding of the narrative’s origins live on stage.

The stage production is part of a broader effort by the creators to expand the “Stranger Things” universe across various media, including novels, comic books, and now, live theater. “Stranger Things: The First Shadow” promises to offer a unique and immersive experience, enriching the backstory of the beloved series and providing new insights into the forces that shaped the town of Hawkins and its inhabitants before the arrival of the Demogorgon.